Year	Result
2021	Vancouver Killer Whales 19, West Virginia Beasts 17
2020	Newark Bulldogs 23, West Virginia Beasts 20
2019	Portland Seals 10, Newark Bulldogs 3
2018	Cleveland Clawz 30, Lawrence Phantoms 27
2017	Pennsylvania Lions 40, Montreal Firebirds 16
2016	Tulsa TigerHawks 14, Portland Seals 6
2015	West Virginia Beasts 34, Tulsa TigerHawks 27
2014	West Virginia Beasts 41, Texas Trojans 23
2013	Lawrence Phantoms 28, Murfreesboro Mules 21
2012	Texas Trojans 41, Cleveland Clawz 20
2011	Lawrence Phantoms 24, Norfolk Vipers 21
2010	Vermont Mountaineers 17, Iowa City Snipe Hunters 14
2009	Hartford Whalers 19, Lawrence Phantoms 14
2008	Norfolk Vipers 24, Madison Demons 7
2007	Little Rock Toads 24, Norfolk Vipers 14
2006	Norfolk Vipers 33, Oakland Assassins 32
2005	St. Louis Cardinals 13, Little Rock Toads 12
2004	Madison Demons 19, Anchorage Lynx 16
2003	Orlando Pirates 24, Cleveland Clawz 6